Get Instant Quote

Find the Best Roofing Material: Home Roofing Guide 2023

Estimated Reading Time : 12 Min.

Share Now :

Find the Best Roofing Material: Home Roofing Guide 2023

When it comes to renovating our homes, we all want the freedom to choose materials that are both durable and budget-friendly. The roof, being one of the most critical parts of the house, requires careful consideration in terms of material choice, especially when working on a tight budget. As experienced homeowners ourselves, we understand how overwhelming this decision can be; that’s why we’ve taken the time to research and compile a comprehensive guide on finding the best roofing material without sacrificing quality.


In this article, we’ll walk you through assessing your roofing needs and exploring various materials available on the market today. We’ll pay particular attention to asphalt shingles – one of the most affordable yet reliable options for your roof renovation project. Furthermore, we’ll share our insights into different types of roofing shingles and discuss financial incentives like rebates and tax credits that might help you save even more money when upgrading your roof. So sit back and relax as we help you navigate through this important decision-making process with ease!


Homeowners considering many options for roof to find best roofing material. They have to choose from such as concrete tiles, green roofs, clay tiles, stone coated steel, rolled roofing, metal shingles, clay tiles, slate roofs, asphalt composite shingles and stone coated steel roofing.

Assessing Roofing Needs Before Selecting The Material

It’s vital to consider what you truly need for your rooftop makeover, without breaking the bank. When assessing your roofing needs, it’s crucial to think about factors such as roofing insulation, gutter systems, and ventilation solutions. We also recommend considering energy efficiency and sustainability when choosing materials for your renovation project. By thoroughly understanding your specific requirements and preferences, we can help you select the most cost-effective options that will not only meet but exceed your expectations.

As experienced professionals in the field of roofing, we understand that there are numerous materials available with varying price tags. However, it’s essential to remember that the cheapest option may not always be the best one in terms of durability and long-term benefits.

So let us guide you through this process to make informed decisions about which materials will best suit your budget while still providing excellent functionality and aesthetics for years to come. With our knowledge and expertise in selecting suitable roofing options that maximize energy efficiency while minimizing environmental impact, we can help you achieve a rooftop makeover that brings the freedom of financial savings along with an eco-friendly lifestyle choice. Together, we’ll create a roof replacement plan tailored specifically to your unique needs – ensuring both quality results and peace of mind throughout every step of the project.

Understanding the Importance of Roofing Materials

When it comes to cutting costs, selecting the right materials is absolutely essential! Material durability, eco-friendly options, insulation benefits, weather resistance, and color variety are all aspects we need to consider when choosing the best and most cost-effective roofing material for our project. A durable material will last longer and won’t require frequent repairs or replacements; this saves us money in the long run. Eco-friendly options may be a bit more expensive upfront but can save on energy bills while also helping the environment. Insulation benefits directly impact our heating and cooling expenses by keeping our homes comfortable during extreme temperatures.

Weather resistance is another important factor to take into account when choosing budget-friendly roofing materials. We want a roof that can withstand harsh weather conditions like heavy rain, strong winds, hailstorms or snow loads without giving way or demanding expensive repairs. Investing in a weather-resistant material ultimately saves us from unforeseen expenses due to damage caused by Mother Nature’s fury. Additionally, having a wide range of colors available to choose from not only adds aesthetic value but also allows us to select lighter shades which can help reflect sunlight and keep our homes cooler during hot summer months.

Selecting an affordable yet reliable roofing material requires thorough research and consideration of various factors that impact its performance as well as our overall budget constraints. Balancing these factors will ensure we make a wise investment that keeps our home protected throughout the years while maintaining control over costs without compromising quality or sustainability goals.

Cheapest Roofing Material for Residential Roof Replacement

Asphalt shingles offer a fantastic blend of affordability, durability, and style – making them an ideal choice for your budget-conscious renovation! Not only are they cost-effective, but they also come in various types and colors, allowing you to customize the look of your roof. Additionally, advancements in technology have led to improvements in this roofing material’s performance and eco-friendliness. In fact, several benefits make asphalt shingles stand out among other options:

  1. Shingle recycling has become more common, providing environmentally conscious homeowners with eco-friendly options.

  2. Fire resistant materials incorporated into these shingles improve safety by reducing the risk of ignition from external fires.

  3. Hail & Wind resistant shingles are available to increase durability against harsh weather conditions.

  4. Cool roof technology being integrated with certain asphalt shingles by several manufacturers to reflect sunlight and reduce heat absorption.

Types of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt roof is the best option among clay tiles roof, concrete tiles roof, green roofs and built-up roofing.

Ready to explore the world of asphalt shingles and find the perfect fit for your home? As you dive into this budget-friendly roofing material, you’ll discover various types of asphalt shingles that can cater to your specific needs. Factors such as energy efficiency, wind resistance, fire resistance, and shingle colors play a significant role in selecting the best type for your home.


Here’s a handy comparison table showing different types of asphalt shingles:


Shingle TypeEnergy EfficiencyWind ResistanceFire Resistance
3-Tab ShinglesModerateFair (60-70 mph)Class A
ArchitecturalHighGood (110-130 mph)Class A
Luxury PremiumExcellent (>130 mph)Class A


When it comes time to install new roofing material on our own homes or clients’ residences, asphalt shingles remain one of our most trusted choices due to their combination of strength and versatility. In the following sections, we’ll provide an overview of the most common asphalt roofing materials and discuss their benefits.

Three-Tab Asphalt Shingles

three tab shingles installed on low slope roofs roof that looks like flat roofs but is not flat roofs

Looking for a classic touch to your home’s exterior? Three-tab composite shingles are the most basic and affordable option available. They provide moderate energy efficiency with a uniform appearance but may not be as durable or resistant to high winds as other options. They are called 3-tab shingles because each shingle is designed with three distinct tabs, giving them a uniform, rectangular appearance.


Affordability: 3-tab shingles are relatively inexpensive, making them a popular residential roofing options.

Wide range of color options: They come in a variety of colors, allowing homeowners to match their roofing with their home’s exterior design.

Ease of installation: 3-tab shingles are lightweight and easy to install, making them a popular choice for DIY projects or quick roofing jobs.

Proven track record: These shingles have been used in the roofing industry for decades, demonstrating their reliability and durability.


Limited wind resistance: 3-tab shingles have a lower wind resistance compared to other types of shingles, such as architectural shingles, which can make them less suitable for areas with high winds.

Shorter lifespan: The average lifespan of 3-tab shingles is around 15-20 years, which is shorter compared to other types of shingles, like architectural shingles that can last up to 30 years or more.

Less aesthetic appeal: Due to their uniform, rectangular appearance, 3-tab shingles may not provide the same level of visual appeal as other types of shingles, like architectural or wood shake shingles.

Prone to curling and buckling: Over time, 3-tab shingles can curl or buckle due to weather exposure, leading to potential leaks and the need for repairs or replacement.

Architectural Asphalt Shingles

Architectural roof shingles with advanced roofing materials

If you’re seeking a stylish yet cost-effective option for your home’s exterior, architectural shingles might just be the perfect choice for you! They are designed with multiple layers of material, which adds depth and dimension to the shingle’s appearance and gives them higher wind resistance. Architectural composite shingles are known for their durability, longevity, and enhanced curb appeal.

 The table below showcases various features and benefits of architectural shingles:


Regional Climate AdaptabilityWithstands diverse weather conditions
Energy EfficiencyReflects sunlight reducing cooling costs
Color Options Wide variety for personalization
Shingle Recycling ProgramsEnvironmentally friendly waste reduction
Architectural AestheticsMimics high-end materials like concrete tiles or wood shingles at a fraction of their cost

Premium Asphalt Shingles

When it comes to premium shingles, you’ll find that these high-end roofing options not only elevate your home’s appearance but also deliver outstanding durability and performance. They can last 25-30 years or more, depending on the manufacturer and specific product.

Luxury shingles can mimic the appearance of natural materials like cedar wood shakes, slate shingles or metal shingles without the associated maintenance concerns. These shingles offer a variety of warranty options, so you can choose the level of protection that best suits your needs. Additionally, they come in a wide array of color selections, allowing you to match them perfectly with your home’s aesthetic.

Although they may be more expensive upfront, investing in a luxury roofing product may result in significant long-term savings due to reduced replacement and maintenance needs.

Best Asphalt Shingle Roofing Option

As experienced roofing professionals, we understand the importance of finding the perfect balance between aesthetics and functionality when selecting best asphalt shingle material for your roof renovation project.

The most economic option is architectural shingles, as they offer a balance between affordability and improved performance compared to traditional 3-tab shingles. Architectural shingles provide a longer lifespan, better wind resistance, and enhanced aesthetics without breaking the bank.

For homeowners seeking the best durability and curb appeal, premium or luxury shingles are the top choice. These high-end shingles provide remarkable durability, superior weather resistance, and eye-catching designs that give the appearance of more costly roofing materials, such as concrete tile roofs, slate roofs, or wood roofs.

Alternatives to Asphalt Shingles

Wood Shingles

Wood styled shingles installed like wood shakes on a existing shingles

If you’re considering other options besides asphalt shingles, wood shingle offers a unique and natural alternative that can enhance the beauty of your home. One of the main advantages of using wood as a roofing material is its sustainability; it’s a renewable resource that can be harvested from responsibly managed forests. Moreover, used wood shingles can be recycled into mulch or other landscaping materials, reducing waste and contributing to a greener environment. However, unlike asphalt shingles that are treated for fire resistance, untreated wood shingles may pose a higher risk in terms of flammability. To mitigate this issue, you can choose fire-resistant wood roofing alternatives such as cedar shakes or pressure-treated shingles.

Another aspect to consider when selecting wood shingles is their performance under different climate conditions. While they provide excellent insulation properties and help maintain comfortable indoor temperatures throughout the year, they might not fare well in extremely wet or humid climates without proper maintenance. Regular sealing and treating will protect your wooden roof from moisture-related damage like rotting, warping, or mold growth – but this also means additional long-term costs compared to other low-maintenance roofing options like asphalt or metal.

Metal Roofs

Metal roof materials installed in hot climates and wet climates area without roofing nails with extra structural support

Don’t let the thought of a metal roof intimidate you; it’s an eco-friendly and one of the most durable roofing materials that can save you money in the long run! With metal roofing materials, you’ll not only be making a smart financial decision but also contributing to metal recycling and sustainability efforts. The variety of color options available for metal roofs allows you to choose a look that complements your home’s design while providing excellent durability. Additionally, modern technology has allowed for noise reduction features in these roofs, ensuring that rain and hail won’t create excessive noise inside your home. Metal roofing is suitable for various climates as it reflects sunlight, keeping your home cooler during hot summer months.

As we’ve mentioned before, one of the main advantages of choosing a metal roof is its longevity. Most metal roofs have a lifespan of 40-70 years – significantly longer than any other roofing options out there. This means less frequent replacement costs for homeowners over time! Furthermore, repairs are generally cheaper and easier to perform on a metal roof compared to other materials. You’ll also appreciate the low-maintenance nature of standing seam metal roofing since it doesn’t attract mold or mildew growth like wood does.

Another key benefit when considering installing a metal roof is its ability to withstand severe weather conditions such as high winds, heavy snowfall, and even fire resistance. This makes them ideal for homes located in areas prone to natural disasters or extreme weather patterns. Also worth noting is their energy efficiency – by reflecting solar heat rather than absorbing it like darker-colored traditional shingles do, they help keep your home cooler during warmer months which translates into lower energy bills overall! So if you’re looking to renovate your roof on a budget with an environmentally friendly option that provides lasting value while saving on long-term maintenance expenses – give serious consideration to going with a metal roof!

Solar Shingles

solar roofing shingles installed in southern California which can help homeowners save money and produce electricity using solar power

Now that we’ve explored the benefits of metal roofs, let’s take a look at another budget-friendly option: solar shingles. These innovative shingles combine the functionality of traditional roofing materials with the energy-saving benefits of solar panels. Now, homeowners no longer have to compromise when adding solar power to their roof. Get a great-looking roof, a single warranty, and solar energy.

Solar shingles are designed to blend seamlessly with your existing roof, creating a sleek and unified appearance. This is especially important for homeowners who want to maintain their home’s curb appeal without sacrificing solar efficiency. However, it’s essential to be aware of installation challenges that may come with this advanced technology. Proper installation is crucial in ensuring optimal energy savings and long-term durability of solar tiles. It may be necessary to enlist the help of experienced professionals who specialize in solar roofing systems.

Tile Roofs

Concrete tile roof installed in Tampa, florida providing thermal insulation to the built up roofs house saving energy costs and potential to last more than a century.

Looking for a stylish and durable option? Tile roofs are not only known for their durability and eco-friendliness, but also for their aesthetics that can greatly enhance the curb appeal of your home. Modern tile designs come in a wide range of styles, colors, and textures, allowing you to customize your roof to perfectly match your personal taste and architectural style. Below are some of the pros of installing concrete roof tiles: 

1. Tile Durability: One of the main reasons homeowners choose tile roofing materials is because they are incredibly durable, often lasting 50 years or more with proper maintenance. This makes them an excellent long-term investment for those looking to renovate on a budget.

2. Eco-Friendly Tiles: Tile roofs are made from natural materials like clay or concrete, which means they’re environmentally friendly options compared to synthetic roofing products like asphalt shingles. Moreover, clay tiles can be recycled at the end of their lifespan, reducing landfill waste.

3. Tile Insulation: Another significant advantage of tile roofs is their natural insulation properties that help regulate indoor temperatures throughout the year—keeping your home cooler in summer months while retaining heat during colder seasons.

Other Factors to Consider When Finding Best Roofing Material

As you explore the world of roofing options, it is important to compare costs and identify the choice that best aligns with your financial requirements and aesthetic preferences. Additional factors, such as energy efficiency, insurance discounts, and regional considerations, are also worth taking into account before deciding on a new roofing material. It’s crucial to strike a balance between these factors when selecting the perfect roofing solution for your home.

  1. Energy Efficiency: Investing in energy-efficient roofing materials can lead to significant savings on heating and cooling bills over time. For example, metal roofs reflect solar heat away from your home during hot summer months, keeping it cooler without requiring as much air conditioning.

  2. Insurance Discounts: Some insurance companies offer discounts for homeowners who install certain types of durable or disaster-resistant roofing materials such as Class 4 impact-resistant shingles or metal roofs. These discounts can help offset higher initial costs while providing long-term protection for your home.

  3. Regional Considerations: Climate conditions vary widely across different regions; therefore, it’s essential to factor in local weather patterns when choosing a roof material. For instance, metal roofing might be ideal for homes located in areas prone to hailstorms since they are highly resistant to damage from hailstones.

When weighing your options and comparing costs, don’t forget about potential rebates or incentives available through local or federal programs for using sustainable roofing materials. These incentives can help offset some of the initial expense associated with more costly environmentally friendly choices. By carefully researching different types of roofing materials’ prices and weighing their benefits against one another in terms of environmental impact, longevity, aesthetics, and ease of maintenance – you’ll be better equipped to choose a roofing solution that fits both your budgetary constraints as well as your desire for freedom when it comes to creating a beautiful yet functional living space.

Final Recommendations

As a roofing contractor with over 20 years of experience and more than 1000 roofs installed, we can offer recommendations based on our expertise to help you find the best-suited residential roofing option. Taking into account budget-friendly choices, sustainability, energy efficiency, recycled materials, and weather resistance, we recommend two top options for your roofing needs. Both of these selections provide a unique combination of benefits that cater to different priorities while still maintaining affordability.

First up is metal roofing. This durable option boasts high levels of energy efficiency due to its reflective properties. Metal roofs can also be made from recycled materials, making them an environmentally friendly choice. Furthermore, this type of roofing material can withstand various weather conditions such as heavy rains and strong winds with ease. While the upfront costs may be higher than some alternatives like asphalt shingles, metal roofs offer a long lifespan and low maintenance requirements, making them a smart investment over time.

Our second recommendation is asphalt shingles—a classic and popular choice among homeowners for being the cheapest roofing material and their ease of installation. Asphalt shingles come in a variety of styles and colors, allowing you to personalize the look of your home without breaking the bank. Although they may not be as sustainable as other options on this list (typically lasting around 20-30 years), advances in manufacturing have improved their performance in terms of energy efficiency and durability against harsh weather conditions.

Ultimately, choosing the best material for your roof depends on your specific needs and preferences. By being informed about the available options, you can confidently make a decision that suits both your budget and requirements in renovating your roof.

Free Consultation on Roofing Options in Tampa, FL

SouthShore Roofing Contractors with the team outside an house in Tampa. SouttShore provides roofing for most common roofing materials such as stone coated steel roofing, membrane roofing, slate roof and rolled roofing.

Understanding the complexities and factors involved in choosing materials for a new roof is crucial, and finding a trustworthy roofing company to handle the job is equally important. At SouthShore Roofing & Exteriors, we take pride in helping homeowners make well-informed decisions when selecting roofing materials. As a certified roofing contractor with years of experience in Tampa and surrounding areas, we have successfully installed hundreds of asphalt, metal, and tile roofs throughout Hillsborough County.

Our expert team is here to guide you through the process of choosing the ideal roofing option for your home. As a local community member, we offer free consultations and estimates to ensure you make the best decision and get excellent value for your investment. With our dedication to quality and 100% customer satisfaction, you can count on us for outstanding roof replacement service in Tampa and nearby areas. Feel free to give us a call at 813-400-3329, and we’ll be more than happy to address your concerns and provide free guidance and quotes.


Skip to content